Vendor Exception Management Examples
Exception management in vendor risk programs requires balancing security requirements with business needs. Successful programs document risk acceptance criteria, implement compensating controls, and establish clear approval workflows. Most organizations manage 15-many vendors through exceptions, typically for legacy systems, sole providers, or strategic partnerships where standard controls aren't feasible.
Key takeaways:
- Define clear exception criteria and approval thresholds based on risk tier
- Implement compensating controls that reduce residual risk to acceptable levels
- Set automatic review cycles (90-180 days) for all active exceptions
- Track exception metrics to identify systemic control gaps
- Document business justification and risk owner accountability
Vendor exception management tests the maturity of your TPRM program. When a critical vendor can't meet your security standards but the business needs them anyway, you need a structured process to evaluate, approve, and monitor the residual risk.
The reality: perfect compliance is rare. A financial services firm discovered a significant number of their tier-1 vendors couldn't provide SOC 2 reports. A healthcare system found their EMR vendor refused right-to-audit clauses. A retail chain's payment processor wouldn't agree to 24-hour breach notification.
These scenarios demand exception management – the controlled acceptance of vendor risk when business value outweighs security concerns. Done right, exceptions become data points that improve your program. Done wrong, they become untracked vulnerabilities in your attack surface.
Real-World Exception Scenarios
Case 1: Legacy System Integration Exception
Background: A Fortune 500 manufacturer relied on a 20-year-old inventory management system from a vendor with 12 employees. The vendor had no security certifications, refused questionnaires, and operated from shared hosting infrastructure.
Risk Profile:
- No SOC 2 or ISO 27001 certification
- Failed 18 of 25 critical security controls
- Processed 2M transactions monthly
- Single point of failure for $400M supply chain
Exception Process:
- Business unit submitted exception request with revenue impact analysis
- TPRM team conducted threat modeling specific to data flows
- Security architecture proposed network segmentation approach
- Legal drafted enhanced liability terms
- CISO and CFO jointly approved 180-day conditional exception
Compensating Controls Implemented:
- Deployed API gateway with rate limiting and anomaly detection
- Restricted vendor access to read-only production data
- Implemented daily backup to secondary system
- Required quarterly penetration testing at company expense
- Established vendor security improvement roadmap with milestones
Outcome: After 18 months, vendor achieved SOC 2 Type I. Exception converted to standard monitoring. Zero security incidents during exception period.
Case 2: Critical SaaS Platform Acquisition Exception
Background: A healthcare network's radiology department selected a cloud-based imaging platform that stored 500,000 patient records. Post-contract, security assessment revealed significant gaps.
Discovered Issues:
- No encryption at rest
- Shared database architecture
- Located in non-HIPAA compliant data center
- 90-day data retention for audit logs (HIPAA requires 6 years)
Exception Timeline:
| Phase | Duration | Actions |
|---|---|---|
| Discovery | Week 1-2 | Security assessment reveals non-compliance |
| Escalation | Week 3 | CISO briefs executive committee on patient data risk |
| Analysis | Week 4-6 | Legal reviews contract termination costs ($2.4M) |
| Decision | Week 7 | Approve 12-month exception with strict conditions |
| Implementation | Week 8-52 | Phased security improvements monitored monthly |
Risk Mitigation Strategy:
- Immediate: Disabled external sharing features, restricted access to on-premise only
- 30 days: Vendor implemented encryption at rest
- 90 days: Migrated to HIPAA-compliant hosting
- 180 days: Achieved logical data separation
- 365 days: Full HITRUST certification
Lessons Learned: Pre-contract security assessment would have saved $400K in remediation costs. Department now requires TPRM approval before vendor selection.
Building Your Exception Framework
Risk-Based Approval Matrix
| Risk Tier | Exception Authority | Max Duration | Review Frequency |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tier 1 (Critical) | CISO + Business Executive | 180 days | Monthly |
| Tier 2 (High) | Director of Risk + VP | 365 days | Quarterly |
| Tier 3 (Medium) | TPRM Manager | 365 days | Semi-annually |
| Tier 4 (Low) | Security Analyst | Indefinite | Annually |
Exception Request Template
Every exception request must document:
- Business Justification: Quantified impact of denial (revenue, operations, compliance)
- Risk Assessment: Specific controls gaps and potential impact
- Compensating Controls: Technical and procedural safeguards
- Success Criteria: Measurable improvements required
- Exit Strategy: Plan if vendor won't remediate
Common Exception Types and Solutions
Missing Certifications
- Scenario: Vendor lacks SOC 2 but handles customer data
- Compensating Control: Quarterly questionnaire + annual penetration test
- Success Metric: Achieve certification within 12 months
Geographic Restrictions
- Scenario: Data hosting in non-approved country
- Compensating Control: Data localization requirements + encryption
- Success Metric: Migration to approved region
Right to Audit Refusal
- Scenario: Vendor won't accept audit clause
- Compensating Control: Third-party assessment + increased monitoring
- Success Metric: Negotiated limited audit rights
Continuous Monitoring During Exceptions
Active exceptions require enhanced monitoring:
Technical Controls:
- API monitoring for anomalous behavior
- Network segmentation and traffic analysis
- Data loss prevention (DLP) rules
- Security event correlation
Administrative Controls:
- Monthly vendor check-ins
- Quarterly control validation
- Executive dashboard reporting
- Automated expiration alerts
Metrics That Matter
Track these KPIs for exception program health:
- Active exceptions by risk tier
- Average time to remediation
- Exception recurrence rate
- Business impact of denied exceptions
- Control improvement velocity
One TPRM manager reduced active exceptions a large share of in one year by publishing monthly metrics showing department leaders their vendor risk exposure compared to peers.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many vendor exceptions are too many?
Industry benchmarks show 15-many vendors under exception management. Above a significant number of indicates overly strict controls or weak vendor vetting. Below a meaningful portion of suggests possible shadow IT.
Should temporary vendors get exceptions?
Short-term vendors (under 90 days) should follow expedited assessment, not exception process. Create a separate "limited engagement" track with simplified controls based on data access.
Can we auto-approve low-risk exceptions?
Yes, with guardrails. Tier 4 vendors meeting specific criteria (no sensitive data, limited access, standard services) can use automated approval with annual review.
What if a vendor refuses compensating controls?
Document the refusal and escalate to business leadership with quantified risk. Either accept higher risk with executive sign-off or initiate vendor replacement.
How do we handle inherited exceptions after M&A?
Conduct rapid risk assessment within 30 days. Grant blanket 90-day grace period, then require standard exception process. Track separately for board reporting.
When should we revoke an exception?
Immediately upon: security incident, missed remediation milestone, change in risk profile, or discovery of undisclosed information. Build revocation triggers into your process.
Do exceptions need board visibility?
Tier 1 vendor exceptions should appear in quarterly board risk reports. Include total count, business impact, and trending. Full details stay at management level.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many vendor exceptions are too many?
Industry benchmarks show 15-30% of vendors under exception management. Above 30% indicates overly strict controls or weak vendor vetting. Below 10% suggests possible shadow IT.
Should temporary vendors get exceptions?
Short-term vendors (under 90 days) should follow expedited assessment, not exception process. Create a separate "limited engagement" track with simplified controls based on data access.
Can we auto-approve low-risk exceptions?
Yes, with guardrails. Tier 4 vendors meeting specific criteria (no sensitive data, limited access, standard services) can use automated approval with annual review.
What if a vendor refuses compensating controls?
Document the refusal and escalate to business leadership with quantified risk. Either accept higher risk with executive sign-off or initiate vendor replacement.
How do we handle inherited exceptions after M&A?
Conduct rapid risk assessment within 30 days. Grant blanket 90-day grace period, then require standard exception process. Track separately for board reporting.
When should we revoke an exception?
Immediately upon: security incident, missed remediation milestone, change in risk profile, or discovery of undisclosed information. Build revocation triggers into your process.
Do exceptions need board visibility?
Tier 1 vendor exceptions should appear in quarterly board risk reports. Include total count, business impact, and trending. Full details stay at management level.
See how Daydream handles this
The scenarios above are exactly what Daydream automates. See it in action.
Get a Demo